Your Custom Text Here
for a proper approach to the big re-write. I only have 3 lines of text to set, and I think that I need about 4 minutes of music, for proportional reasons. Tonight I had a flash of inspiration for a striking opening.
This week I have a Chamber Choir project, so I will get very little composition done, but I might spend my evenings orchestrating ACC2.
I took a break from actually sitting down and composing for extended periods of time today and yesterday. I just needed some space from the PhD piece. I put together some sketches for a new opening of ACC5, which I’ll work on in a week after I finish Before Bach and After 4 with the Chamber Choir. Today I mostly spent my time prepping 6 new pieces for publication with Cailino Music Publishers, which is exciting! I just need to chase down published sources for 4 of my texts and it’s all good to go.
I also started sketching one of my 4 Christmas Carols for Chamber Choir to sing later this year. I had been going to leave these until I’d done a bit more of my PhD, but again, it’s good to get some space from that, while still being productive. In this case, I started work on The Morningstar, which is going to be a sort of arrangement of the first verse of the hymn “How Brightly Beams the Morning Star.”. I say “sort of arrangement” because while it will be heavily based on that tune, and almost always recognisably so, It’ll be heard through layers and layers of shimmery wrapping paper. How festive!
So I’ve tentatively started (again) the re-write of movement 5 of ACC. I have a new idea – one that has been fermenting for a few days, and that caused me to realise that what I had been working on wasn’t working. I feel that it’s a very strong idea, and the temptation to jump straight into sibelius and start working through it is very strong.
That’s exactly what went wrong last time. I have learned, time and again, that the approach to composition that works best for me is to lay a solid foundation on paper first – come up with all the key musical building blocks, map out where they’re going to go. Then I put those into sibelius, with big gaps in between, and fill it in later. If there’s a lot of filling in to do, then the process repeats. If it’s just little bits, then I can usually get away with doing that straight into sibelius.
This approach can make supervisions a little tricky sometimes. I send my long-suffering supervisor, Dr Phill, about 30 pages of music, lots of which is blank, lots of which is fragmentary, and hope that I can somehow explain to him how this sketch of a blueprint is going to look and sound when it’s finished.
In the case of the big re-write I had not done my homework. I had not laid my foundations and selected my materials. I’d come up with one or two rough-hewn ideas, and gone ahead with putting it all together before I even really knew how the pieces fit. The end result? Dustbin
It’s a funny old thing, creativity. Sometimes you get swept up in an idea or a concept, sticking to it even though it’s clearly not working. I realised today (after writing what I think is a truly stunning bridge between section a and section b of ACC 5) that most of section a is not good. I had become so invested in this idea of the ‘1-3-1’ scale that I couldn’t see that I simply wasn’t able to make it work. I may be able to use that scale in future, but for what I’m writing, it’s just not suitable. So this afternoon, after a quick lunch and a phone call to Dominica, I scrapped the work of a week and a half and am starting again. I’m going to be using a rhythmic and melodic idea from ACC 3, which is the first movement I composed, and I think it’ll be a lot more coherent than it had been previously. I only have 3 lines of text to re-set, but I’m hoping 3rd time’s the charm.
This isn’t the first time I’ve had to do this. When I was writing The Falling Tear, I went through 2 different version, both of which I binned, before settling on the version you can hear on youtube. I actually sent the 1st version to Phillip, my supervisor, a couple of days before a supervision meeting, and then the 2nd version at 3 o clock on the morning of that supervision. He – quite rightly – said that I was in the right ball park, but was barking up the wrong goal post. He said the same about the 1st version of this that I sent him in October, and something similar about the 2nd version, only a sketch of which I sent him, last time I saw him in Aberdeen.
However, sometimes it’s good to get these things out of your system. It’s good to spend a while on something, get it semi-formed (or even fully-formed), so that you can haul it out into the light of day, see that it’s rife with inadequacies, almost unsalvageable, and bin it. There’s no chance of a niggling suspicion lurking at the back of your brain that maybe it would have worked if you’d stuck with it.
I stuck with it, and it didn’t work. So I’m binning it, and I’m moving on.
I use quotation a lot in my music. If I’m writing a choral piece or a song, and I can refer to another piece of music that deals with the same or similar text, I’ll often throw in a chunk of someone else’s music to spice things up a bit. My first treatment of this, so far as I can remember, was in using a notable chord progression from Vierne’s Berceuse in the Nunc Dimittis of my Faux Bourdons. A Berceuse is an evening piece, and a Nunc Dimittis is an evening canticle, sung by Simeon in the evening of his life, so it felt right.
My PhD piece is being brought together by quotations from the hymn tune Columba: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sds1oHhFFSo
The opening rise and fall is the subject of my fugue:
Columba opening phrase, in 5/4 with a raised 4th (gotta have that Lydian flavour!)
And the first 2 phrases are the canon from the beginning of ACC 5 that I’ve been working on.
This time, it’s been modified to fit into a “1,3,1” scale that I’m using, but still with the raised 4th to fit into my overall Lydian approach.
And last night and today, I realised that the beginning of the 3rd phrase would work really nicely as the bridge from the 1st half of ACC 5 into the 2nd.
Bridge – Work in Progress
Which also ties it in nicely with the big passacaglia I wrote for the beginning of ACC 7
Passacaglia – Fragment
There is a recurring bell motif that happens throughout the piece. Until today, I wasn’t happy with any of the actual motifs I’d come up with. The beginnings were fine, but the endings were not. The ending is now going to be this 3rd phrase, and so, the whole piece will tie in together, bound by this one hymn tune, which is never explicitly stated – only played around with.
There is a similar treatment in the 3rd movement of The Falling Tear, which I think of as a toccata-fantasia on King Jesus Hath a Garden. Listen to that here: https://youtu.be/f5uqXGmD7Fg?t=334
My canons before my cat-assistant came in and helped.
My canons after my cat-assistant came in and helped.
After a very slow week, I’m finally back into the swing of composition. The whole of the skeleton of the big re-write is done. I just need to write all the string parts and lots of the choral parts – simple!
Next week I’ll be back on track, writing the string parts of my 2nd movement in the evenings – expect lots and lots of sul ponticello.
My work at the moment is so boring that I’ve decided just to share Borodin’s second String Quartet for day 27. Some of you may recognise the slow movement!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YAzUC6LzNk
And the last bit of structural decision making is finally done. I hope.
Funny thing about writing post-tonal canons is that you get some seriously gnarly accidentals:
My tenor and bass canon for ACC 5, feat my pj bottoms and my Majora’s Mask Mouse pad.
Check out those delish double flats. Might change the whole passage to sharps, but where’s the challenge in that?
Before his triumph, for a time he was in torment
The above quote is the first line of my big re-write. In some ways, it’s going well, and in other ways, it’s not. More than any other piece I’ve written since my MPhil, I just can’t get into the groove of this one. I’ve only got 4 lines left to re-write, but every time I do something with them, I have another idea, and suddenly, all my previous ideas seem moronic and useless. I have a general shape of how I want it to go, but getting it down is like pulling teeth. I was going to focus on this movement all next week, but the imposter syndrome is growing, so I might put it away for a couple of days and focus on orchestrating the second movement.
The big re-write is coming along. As I’m basically just pouring material into a mould, there’s very little to blog about, so I might put this on hiatus over the weekend. I’m a few days behind, but fortunately, I’ve got a buffer zone of 3 weeks at the end of my plan for this kind of thing. I’d hoped to focus on the second movement next week, but it will probably be better for me to keep working away at the 5th movement until it’s done!
About the blog:
Words, words, words. Sometimes pictures.